Vitavonni

Sat, 18 Aug 2007

More (ranting) on Skype

A couple of people have pointed me to the "Skype DoS exploit code" that has been published. I had seen that, but I'm not convinced it works as simple as that. Some of the information around it doesn't make completely sense (such as using the term 'server', when they're referring to super nodes I guess, and since supernodes are just regular user machines annexed by the Skype network, they supposedly run the same software, don't they? So why doesn't it take down the client the exploit is run on?

Also I'd bet that someone has tried feeding the Skype client long URIs before; that is one of the most popular ways of seeing if some software can break. You know, Buffer Overflow [wikipedia] is probably the most common class of security issues (maybe second only to PHP programming errors or SQL injection by now, though, with so many people with too little expertise writing webapps in PHP)

Others probably are wondering why I'm writing so much "against" Skype.

There are numerous reasons:

  • The whole P2P thing isn't necessary, they could use real servers
  • Skype is a pain for every network admin (and thus a users nightmare, since the admin might decide to just block any traffic that could be Skype, and enforce the use of HTTP proxies etc. and thus limiting other applications as well)
  • Skype uses all kinds of shady coding techniques in their client to obfuscate what their application is actually doing
  • Skype is a security risk
  • Skype is a memory hog (it uses 10 times as much memory as my other IM client, who does ICQ, MSN, Yahoo, Google Talk and tons of others!)
  • It's a resource hog (it wakes up 200 times as second for nothing, thus preventing my CPU from using power saving states efficiently)
  • It's a closed protocol and network, while there are open industry standards such as SIP [wikipedia] and H.323 [wikipedia] that can do much more than Skype
  • It's UI is crap (especially Linux version 1.4 is a serious degradation vs. version 1.3), contrary to any usability best practises
  • Their API is crap. I'd call that "raping" the DBus API what they're doing (basically they're offering a DBus interface that is just a transport wrapper for a text-based 'telnet-like' API. You know, DBus interfaces are meant to have meaningful functionality (like 'make a phone call') and not meant to be just "send data to the skype application")
  • They don't tell the truth. Like e.g. what has really been happening these days. Or what their software really does (see 'obfuscation' above and search for "Silver Needle In The Skype")

And, honest, there is nothing in Skype that other apps wouldn't offer, or had been offering before except being really aggressive at getting through firewalls without any user intervention.

[category: /en | Permalink]
Menu
[planet.debian]
[planet.xmlhack]
[planet SELinux]
[munichblogs]
[email]
[RSS 2 feed]
[English RSS 2]
Categories
< August 2007 >
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
    1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 91011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031 
Archives
2010-Mar
2010-Feb
2010-Jan
2009-Dec
2009-Nov
2009-Oct
2009-Sep
2009-Aug
2009-Jul
2009-Jun
2009-May
2009-Apr
2009-Mar
2009-Feb
2009-Jan
2008-Dec
2008-Nov
2008-Oct
2008-Sep
2008-Aug
2008-Jul
2008-May
2008-Apr
2008-Mar
2008-Feb
2008-Jan
2007-Dec
2007-Nov
2007-Oct
2007-Sep
2007-Aug
2007-Jul
2007-Jun
2007-May
2007-Apr
2007-Mar
2007-Feb
2007-Jan
2006-Dec
2006-Nov
2006-Oct
2006-Sep
2006-Aug
2006-Jul
2006-Jun
2006-May
2006-Apr
2006-Mar
2006-Feb
2006-Jan
2005-Dec
2005-Nov
2005-Oct
2005-Sep
2005-Aug
2005-Jul
2005-Jun
2005-May
2005-Apr
2005-Mar
2005-Feb
2005-Jan
2004-Dec
2004-Nov
2004-Oct
2004-Sep
2004-Aug
2004-Jul
Other links:
Swing and the City - Lindy Hop in Munich